The Top 10 Italian Wines, by the Gentleman magazine, acknowledges wines that received the highest scores from both Italian and international critics:
- Sassicaia 2018 by Tenuta San Guido
- Solaia 2018 by Antinori
- Masseto 2018 by Ornellaia–Frescobaldi
- San Leonardo 2016 by Tenuta San Leonardo
- Montefalco Sagrantino by Arnaldo Caprai
- Tignanello by Antinori
- I Sodi di S.Niccolò 2017 by Castellare di Castellina
- Baffonero 2018 by Rocca di Frassinello
- Amarone 2017 by Allegrini
- Bolgheri Guado al Tasso 2018 by Antinori and Fratta 2017 by Maculan
Every year Gentleman magazine extrapolates the ranking by crossing the scores of 6 of the most important Italian wine guides:
- Vini d’Italia by Gambero Rosso
- I Vini di Veronelli
- Bibenda by Fondazione Italiana Sommelier
- Vitae by Associazione Italiana Sommelier
- Annuario dei Migliori Vini Italiani by Luca Maroni
- Guida Essenziale ai Vini d’Italia by Daniele Cernilli
In addition, it also checks some of the most authoritative voices of international criticism, such as:
- Wine Spectator
- Robert Parker Wine Advocate (whose signature from Italy is Monica Larner)
- Antonio Galloni Vinous
- James Suckling